Uploaded image for project: 'eZ Publish / Platform'
  1. eZ Publish / Platform
  2. EZP-27914

As an Editor I want to remove permanently a language from a content item

    Details

      Description

      1.x feature only.
      See chapter of the specification "remove permanently an item from a content item"

        Issue Links

          Activity

          Show
          Adam Wójs added a comment - PR: https://github.com/ezsystems/PlatformUIBundle/pull/949
          Hide
          Michał Szołtysek added a comment -

          QA Approved with eZ Platform & eZ Platform EE v1.13.1-rc1 with platform-ui-bundle v1.13.1-rc2.

          Show
          Michał Szołtysek added a comment - QA Approved with eZ Platform & eZ Platform EE v1.13.1-rc1 with platform-ui-bundle v1.13.1-rc2.
          Hide
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment -

          Hello,

          After installing v1.13.1 that has been release a few days ago, I can't senn any improvement on this point. Do you have any feedback ? Thx

          PJ

          Show
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment - Hello, After installing v1.13.1 that has been release a few days ago, I can't senn any improvement on this point. Do you have any feedback ? Thx PJ
          Hide
          Michał Szołtysek added a comment -

          Hello Pierre-Julien Cazaux, do you mean that you cannot see the trash icon on the Existing Translations pop-up next to the translations on the list? (There has to be more than one translation for the icon to be visible.)
          Could you provide the output of composer show | grep ezsystems in the root of your project installation?

          Show
          Michał Szołtysek added a comment - Hello Pierre-Julien Cazaux , do you mean that you cannot see the trash icon on the Existing Translations pop-up next to the translations on the list? (There has to be more than one translation for the icon to be visible.) Could you provide the output of composer show | grep ezsystems in the root of your project installation?
          Hide
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment -

          Hello Michał Szołtysek,

          Thx for this feedback. A can indeed now see the trash icon at the very location Unfortunatelly, For a given element either :

          • the transation is deleted without any trash process (what could be acceptable but not consistent with eZ experience)
          • an error is displayed "Cannot delete main translation from content." (what is not consistent in termes of content management)

          So I would say we did some progress but we are not done yet with this topic.

          Thank you in advance,
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux

          Show
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment - Hello Michał Szołtysek, Thx for this feedback. A can indeed now see the trash icon at the very location Unfortunatelly, For a given element either : the transation is deleted without any trash process (what could be acceptable but not consistent with eZ experience) an error is displayed "Cannot delete main translation from content." (what is not consistent in termes of content management) So I would say we did some progress but we are not done yet with this topic. Thank you in advance, Pierre-Julien Cazaux
          Hide
          André Rømcke added a comment -

          Hi Pierre-Julien,

          > the translation is deleted without any trash process (what could be acceptable but not consistent with eZ experience)

          Then seems we might have overlooked something during your requests for this feature. Trash of translation was not a feature which existed in eZ Publish before so that was never part of the intended scope here. It will have to involve a larger change to how trash works as it is content (including all translations) centric today. So any such change would be a somewhat major change to logic and API's, something we would need to request from our product team for considering placing on the roadmap for future releases.

          > an error is displayed "Cannot delete main translation from content." (what is not consistent in terms of content management)

          This sounds like something we should improve on. For instance disabling the button on main translations with help text making editor aware they can not delete main translation, and thus would need to change main translation. Or simply not exposing the button. This is already the case on v2, and we thus should reflect the same logic on v1.13. Being able to change main translation is a feature I know will most likely be added in v2 in a future release to be able to delete the original langue of a content item (main).

          Last part on changing main language I can't really promise for v1.13 as dedicated translation tab was added first in v2.0 and thus not available as a feature in 1.x. However maybe this is not the most pressing need for you yet given your original use cases seemed to imply you mainly needed to delete additional translations which might contain mistakes, as opposed to removing the original source of the content which often is solved by deleting or hiding the content itself.

          Regardless of which of these features / changes you would like to request, may I ask that you move this discussion to email thread with productmanagement@ez.no. As this public issue has been technically solved and shipped as part of a release already it will soon be closed, so not the most optimal place for the discussion on followup features / improvements / issues.

          Best regards,
          André Rømcke
          VP Customer Success

          Show
          André Rømcke added a comment - Hi Pierre-Julien, > the translation is deleted without any trash process (what could be acceptable but not consistent with eZ experience) Then seems we might have overlooked something during your requests for this feature. Trash of translation was not a feature which existed in eZ Publish before so that was never part of the intended scope here. It will have to involve a larger change to how trash works as it is content (including all translations) centric today. So any such change would be a somewhat major change to logic and API's, something we would need to request from our product team for considering placing on the roadmap for future releases. > an error is displayed "Cannot delete main translation from content." (what is not consistent in terms of content management) This sounds like something we should improve on. For instance disabling the button on main translations with help text making editor aware they can not delete main translation, and thus would need to change main translation. Or simply not exposing the button. This is already the case on v2, and we thus should reflect the same logic on v1.13. Being able to change main translation is a feature I know will most likely be added in v2 in a future release to be able to delete the original langue of a content item (main). Last part on changing main language I can't really promise for v1.13 as dedicated translation tab was added first in v2.0 and thus not available as a feature in 1.x. However maybe this is not the most pressing need for you yet given your original use cases seemed to imply you mainly needed to delete additional translations which might contain mistakes, as opposed to removing the original source of the content which often is solved by deleting or hiding the content itself. Regardless of which of these features / changes you would like to request, may I ask that you move this discussion to email thread with productmanagement@ez.no . As this public issue has been technically solved and shipped as part of a release already it will soon be closed, so not the most optimal place for the discussion on followup features / improvements / issues. Best regards, André Rømcke VP Customer Success
          Hide
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment -

          All right, I will provide this feedback to my customer and will see if enough or require more
          Thx again

          Show
          Pierre-Julien Cazaux added a comment - All right, I will provide this feedback to my customer and will see if enough or require more Thx again
          Hide
          Konrad Oboza added a comment -

          Dear Pierre-Julien,

          this public issue is technically solved, therefore I am closing it. The improvement regarding disabling button for deleting main translation will be a part of the upcoming v1.13.2 release. You can read more about it in a public ticket: https://jira.ez.no/browse/EZP-28966.


          Best regards,
          Konrad Oboza
          Product Support Engineer

          Show
          Konrad Oboza added a comment - Dear Pierre-Julien, this public issue is technically solved, therefore I am closing it. The improvement regarding disabling button for deleting main translation will be a part of the upcoming v1.13.2 release. You can read more about it in a public ticket: https://jira.ez.no/browse/EZP-28966 . — Best regards, Konrad Oboza Product Support Engineer

            People

            • Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              Roland Benedetti
            • Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              6 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: